The Sorrow and the Shame


Vast tracts of the Highlands offer arable land, fit for modern farming methods

If clearing people from their land by force is not cleansing, what is it?

The term ethnic cleansing to denote over a hundred years of clearing Scots from their land is a phrase rejected by those who see Scotland’s ills issuing from its weather, strange culinary habits, an odd language, and a people a little too inclined to be chippy. Alba, it seems, is full of vexatious people who do nothing but complain.

Using ‘cleansing’ is condemned as out of context, erroneously contemporaneous, too emotional because it was often Scot against Scot that did the dirty work.

Well, I have news for slimy proselytisers. It was Jewish guards given temporary preferment who hustled Jews to the gas chambers, less their belongings and clothes. They had no choice. It was do or die. Who would dare not call that barbarity a cleansing?

Evictions, deportation in all weathers cause deaths, especially of children, pregnant mothers and the elderly. Many Scots died from the vicissitudes that befell them, some from losing their wits, and more perished on the emigrant ships.

After the battle of Culloden – its repercussions I explain later – British rule arrived with a vengeance. New laws and taxes were imposed on Scotland leaving only the most rebellious prepared to protest. Clan chiefs found themselves in the invidious position of being landlords forced to report on their clan’s behaviour monthly to prove they were loyal to the British Crown and keeping the peace.

Colonial power always avers it’s for your own good

The Clearances – and I refer to both the Lowlands cleansing as well as the Highlands, were carried out over decades not a few intense years, often without witness or written record. You have to search for court summonses and eviction orders, or rely on the oral tradition to find detail of village clearances.

Those who died on the journey south or out of Scotland given an unmarked pauper’s grave. Keep in mind, only 7% of Scotland’s population lived in large towns making it fairly easy to evict people living in remote areas, and do it without fear of reprisal.

The heartless try to tell us life was hard, houses hovel; people lived in appalling conditions, a truism of other agrarian societies in France, Italy, Spain, and most of the Balkan countries, none of which cried out for English intervention to restore them to economic health. The ‘hard life’ theme is the apology for clearing thousands off the land they tilled and their forefathers before them.

English rural dwellers encountered a similar fate when Westminster decided full-blown capitalism was a core principle goal of a civilised nation, workers needed for the industrial revolution, but in Scotland evictions were comprehensive, enforced, savage and relentless.

There were two distinct types of ‘clearance’. The first was forced settlement on barren land usually near the sea. Homes were burnt and tenants forced to leave at the point of a sword or musket, carrying little or nothing as they headed towards an unknown fate.

Clearances of 2,000 a day were not uncommon. Forced eviction was one method, draconian rent increases another.


A kelp cart used by farmers pushed to the sea’s edge

A lack of documentation is not a lack of evidence

An absence of an official record is very convenient. It allows discounters of history freedom to claim almost anything they want. They can describe lost communities as progress, villages ‘abandoned‘ rather than the vestiges of evictions. They can avoid the pain and suffering, they can dismiss the stench of authoritarian rule. They don’t have to talk about individuals or specific families; they can talk in generalities and platitudes.

Sadly for apologists there are written accounts. Here is one, published in book form, (I have a copy) by the eminent geologist Sir Archibald Geikie, an honest witness to evictions on the Isle of Skye. Readers will forgive his use of ‘valley’ that should be glen.

“I had heard rumours of these intentions to clear people off their land but did not realise they were in the process of being carried out in effect until one afternoon, as I was returning from my ramble, a strange wailing sound reached my ears at intervals on the breeze. On gaining the top of one of the hills on the south side of the valley I could see a long and motley procession winding along the road that led north from Suishnish. It halted at the point of the road opposite Kilbride, and there the lamentation became long and loud. As I drew nearer, I could see that the minister with his wife and daughters had come out to meet the people and bid them all farewell. It was a miscellaneous gathering of at least three generations of crofters. There were old men and women, too feeble to walk, who were placed in carts; the younger members of the community on foot were carrying their bundles of clothes and household effects, while the children, with looks of alarm, walked alongside. There was a pause in the notes of woe as a last word was exchanged with the family of Kilbride. Everyone was in tears; each wished to clasp the hands that had so often be-friended them, and it seemed as if they could not tear themselves away. When they set forth, a cry of grief went up to heaven, the long plaintive wail, like a funeral coronach, was resumed, and after the last of the emigrants had disappeared behind the hill, the sound seemed to re-echo through the whole valley of Strath in one prolonged note of desolation. The people were on their way to be shipped to Canada.”

Once the Treaty was signed in 1707, the Acts of Union a year later, and after the failed resurrection against English rule at the Battle of Culloden in 1745, when ‘Butcher’ Cumberland committed genocide against survivors and innocents, British authorities acted hard and decisively to suppress clan loyalties.

British imperialism has rarely confined itself to extractor of wealth and resources. Imperial rule has to alter a non-English speaking society to its own image in order to sustain its hold over the people and the land. You enslave a people and then teach them how to play cricket to show you mean no harm, and to give the false impression they are one of you. In the case of the Clearances the tale of repression included prohibitions, brutal laws, taxation without representation, and the suppression of language.

 A musket barrel’s perspective of the Clearances

1708: England increases taxes on the Scottish population to be collected by clan chiefs, the annual sum gathered to repay half the loan given to Scottish nobles who lost money on the Darien Schemes, the schemes blocked by England’s trade war.

1720: The Disarming of the Clans Act forces warriors and their families to leave Scotland.

1725: Propelled by sustained unrest over the Act of Union, General Wade upgrades cattle trails to proper roads and bridges – from one English loyal garrison to another.

1730: England’s demand for cattle and sheep increase ten-fold – the Highlands the place to graze them. Clan chiefs encouraged to shift their people off the best ground.

1735: Clearances begin in earnest, emigration rate rises dramatically.

1746: After the Battle of Culloden Highland stragglers, those without a home – sent to the Caribbean as slaves.

1747: Act of Proscription – wearing of tartan banned; the teaching of Gaelic banned; the gathering of clan members banned; playing bagpipes banned; hoarding weapons banned. English language made first language.

1747: Heritable Jurisdiction Act imposed – Highland landowners must accept English rule or forfeit their land. Many clan chiefs step down and move south, some to London.

1762: Clearances is full spate all over the Highlands and spreads to the Lowlands. Some Lowland villages flattened to incorporate the land into a single one-owner estate.

1782: Loch Quoich – flocks of sheep replace 500 souls forced to emigrate to Canada.

1782: Westminster decides Scotland’s rebellious nature is tamed and the Proscription Act is repealed. But remaining clan members stay mere tenants.

1788: Donald Cameron of Lochiel begins clearing his lands of villagers and farmers.

1791: Records show over 7,000 people emigrated from Inverness and Ross lands.

1792: The ‘Year of the Sheep’ – it is estimated that there are now more sheep than people North West of Perth. Sheep deemed ‘more profitable than farming’.

1792: Sir John Sinclair of Ulbster introduces vast flocks of Cheviot sheep to Caithness, ‘four footed clansmen’ replace people, two for one.

1800: Edinburgh and Glasgow turn cities as Highlanders and Lowlanders leave the land.

1807: Highland economy collapses. This is the excuse given for the need to reuse land for ‘better’ purposes. A calamity wholly man made is exploited to propel greed.

1811: Clearances begin in earnest in Sutherland under the auspices of the Duke and Duchess of Sutherland. In 1811 the scattered population was recorded at 1,574. By 1831 the number was 257, most serving the Duke’s estate.

1816: Patrick Sellar, a factor who burned down cottages, walks free from court.

1820: Landlords propose ‘crofting villages’ as enclaves of cheap or free labour.

1846: First serious potato famine speeds up Clearances once more.

1853: Women in Gruinard village, (Greenyards) Ardgay, Strathcarron, their men absent, soldiers fighting in the Crimean war, repel Glaswegian police for weeks, by guile and  ploys, attempting to evict them. Police finally succeed with bloody baton charge.

1900-1958: With two world wars concentrating the British mind, Clearances continue without pause placing great swathes of Scotland in the hands of a few wealthy owners, leaving tenants with few rights.

1960 – Present: Large tracts of supposedly infertile land in the Highlands and many Islands change hands for millions of pounds, Gruinyards included.


Those who resisted eviction saw their home razed to the ground

Freedoms never arrive with colonial rule.

If there exist still people in Scotland who think they are safe under British rule they are condemning themselves and the rest of us to the destruction of Scotland as a nation state. Can you understand the fury that issues from being a perpetual colony?

What difference is there between the vengeance exacted upon Scotland after Culloden, and the reprisals enacted by Westminster now? The repercussions from that lost plebiscite on the fateful 18th of September, 2014 are barbed wire ‘Made in England’.

In no special order: artificial austerity imposed on a wealthy nation, forced withdrawal from Europe, grabbing of Scotland’s powers by Westminster; loss of welfare rights and pensions, forced repatriation; Scots regiments moved south, shared institutions closed in Scotland, empty shipyards where naval vessels were promised, removal of worker protection rights; bedroom tax; the drip, drip withdrawal of the Barnett Formula, theft of Scotland’s oil, the swell of English xenophobia infecting British life, sustained smearing of our Parliament as a useless executive – they all amount to teaching the natives a lesson they won’t forget.

The people who voted against Scotland’s right to govern its self once more, those who blocked a wealthy country from its legitimate civil rights, are petty accomplices in the clearances of modern Scotland. What they missed was obvious. We are at a point where Westminster under Tory and its alter ego Labour aim to keep the populace uncertain, busy watching our backs, our tomorrows not quite guaranteed. They are imposing constant political upheaval, or as Karl Marx put it, “an uninterrupted disturbance of social conditions, everlasting uncertainty and agitation”.

Liberty happiness, autonomy, individuality, spirituality, self-guided development are ideals we all are heir to. There is only one way to realise the clamour for Scotland’s permanent freedom, and it isn’t inviting more tourists to visit the Highlands to take picturesque snapshots of a banished civilisation.

In the face of increasing colonial power where one nation is manipulating the other, Scotland’s worst enemy is apathy and passivity. Toss away the hand-me-down sliver of Union Jack. The label should read ‘Made in Scotland’.



NOTE: Part 2 of this essay: “A Letter from the Clearances“:

NOTE: See also: ‘Scotland’s Emigrants’.

This entry was posted in Scottish Independence Referendum, Scottish Politics. Bookmark the permalink.

75 Responses to The Sorrow and the Shame

  1. Grouse Beater says:

    It will involve re-study of some of the Land and Tenant Commissions and Reports that grew up along the way, probably finishing at the current scare about tree planting.

    The root problem (excuse the pun) is the age-old one – land ownership and how to wrestle the largest part of it back into state’s hands without burdening the state with its running costs. Investment to establish new villages is, or should be, a prime target, something that can’t be done while land lies in so few hands.

    I never know whether I am at a disadvantage close friends with the wealthy or am privileged in able to argue the case with them over a glass of wine. Unsurprisingly, some are sympathetic to the cause, one a closet indy, but they must know their time is running out.

    So, yes, another essay might arrive on modern Clearances but readers need some levity now and again, even if based on historical anecdotes, just to lessen the pain of knowing we’re still a colony.

    I see a rise in requests for a compendium of essays in a book; very flattering, costly to me. I run this site on my personal earnings.

    Maybe I should consider crowd funding, you know, buy a copy in advance, that sort of thing.

  2. Thank you for such an excellent piece of work. Being English and having recently moved to Mull, I was oblivious to all this history (much to my shame) and was in the process of discovering to my horror the realities behind the abandoned villages and settlements, some of which only a stone’s throw from my home. Your eloquent words and timeline description have left me bereft of words powerful enough to express my thoughts and emotions. Thank you again and much respect for writing such an outstanding article.

  3. Grouse Beater says:

    I am pleased to have shone a light on a small portion of my nation’s history. Do show the essay to others, and join me here each weekend for more. Warm regards GB

  4. Excellent piece, Grouse Beater. Have only just discovered your blog and started to follow. Will share with as many will care to read. There is no truer sorrow than those whom are ignorant of their own history. Saoirse.

  5. Grouse Beater says:

    Thank you. Yes, gratifying others will read it, whether sympathetic or already knowledgeable.

  6. A very good read. Well done.

  7. Reblogged this on Douglas and commented:
    This is a very good read, and will explain to many as to how our ancestors ended up in Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the US.
    Indeed it explains how my Great, Great Grandfather ended up in the slums of industrial Birmingham, like so many other Scots.

  8. Grouse Beater says:

    You’re welcome. I don’t mind reblogging, it helps spread the Word! 🙂

  9. Grouse Beater says:

    Thanks again, Clan Douglas. Haste ye back.

  10. This is a part of history not taught at school it was all about the British empire, yes, it is time for Scotland to stand up and be counted. Thank you for the fascinating read and please keep spreading the word.

  11. Roger Bussey says:

    An interesting account of Scotland’s forgotten history…

  12. Anne Lawrie says:

    Please put all this in a book. So many would be happy to crowdfund or order advance copies. This is the history of our country that is hidden or glossed over.

  13. Grouse Beater says:

    Flattered you should suggest a compendium – I have been asked, but probably would need to get it privately published, and on a crowd funded account – “The Best of Grouse Beater”. I’m aware the essays are good as quick references, for research in talks or debates. Others chosen for publication I’d need to refine or update. My natural anxiety is to be faced with only a handful of prospective buyers and a large bill to pay.

  14. Britnatsies?

    Rather than calling certain people ‘Unionist’;
    Remembering the Union was bought and sold,
    No such Union ever really and truly did exist:
    Regaining Scotland’s independence is foretold!

    © Ewen A. Morrison

    Thank you for this importantly informative piece – Scotland/Alba has suffered needlessly… we may have much to ponder! Who among us can we presently blame and can be entirely free of this county’s historic apathy? Nowadays, Scotland’s population has access to information that our predecessors did not have! Perhaps, we are learning this because our generation is actually able and willing to correct those historical wrongs?

    Saor Alba Gu Brath!

  15. Reblogged this on Gabriel & Hare and commented:
    Like the Balkans in many ways, over the centuries.

  16. Pingback: "Let's Not Forget" about clearing people from their land by force… – New Scotland

  17. Christine Cameron says:

    why do people that write about Scotland only write half truths.

  18. Grouse Beater says:

    A good question, Christine. I’ll try to answer it; probably so the natives don’t become restless.

  19. Brian Dempsey says:

    Wonderful blog, never knew half of this at all. To be still treated as a colony to this day is outrageous, hopefully we will take back control in the next few years. Have shared this across a couple of FB groups and the general response is similar to mine. Mostly taught “British” history back in schooldays aka “English colonial history”. Thank you once again.

  20. Grouse Beater says:

    You’re welcome, Brian. And welcome. The more you share and they in turn share, the more it spurs me into greater effort. Thank you. 🙂

  21. tommyaikenhead says:

    Why not get this published GB? Could it be that no serious publisher would touch such a toxic cocktail of half truths and de-contextualized ‘facts’?

    David Baddiel this week aired his excellent documentary on holocaust denial and historical revisionism, and opined ‘conspiracy theories allow idiots to feel like intellectuals’, this blog proves Baddiel 100% correct. At best its a pseudo intellectual blow hard throwing red meat to the hard of thinking, at worst its a crass misrepresentation of the truth with dangerous consequences.

  22. Grouse Beater says:

    Been thinking about a compendium of the most topical essays, and yes, that one would feature pride of place.

  23. FlikeNoir says:

    Costs nothing to publish via KDP. That’s the fastest way we could get the ToUA out and without cost to ourselves. It ended up being almost £5500 for 320 hardbacks published privately, so I’d recommend KDP to get your information out there.

  24. Susan Preston says:

    Not wanting to break your rules, but wanting to draw attention to this I copied the first paragraph and said it is re-blogged from this site with a link back to the full article. I will remove it if you don’t approve. Link to my re-blog

  25. Grouse Beater says:

    I only object if my work is republished by others for commercial gain.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s