A Churchillian Hatred


Jackson Carlaw, one of the many carpetbaggers paid to keep Scotland servile

Things happen in threes. Three times in one week I’ve heard the same comment. The first from a friend, an intelligent man, runs his own computer servicing business, the guy you call to locate the virus and install security systems, a staunch independence voter. The second was on an e-mail, the third on a tweet.

My friend said, “It’s all getting too divisive; we voted with the United Kingdom, maybe  we should accept the result of Brexit.”

Whatever he said next, I didn’t hear. I rolled his words over in my mind trying to make sense of them. What he had said was irrational. Either you understand and acknowledge Scotland is a separate nation from England, or you accept the colonial view that it’s north Britain in everything except name. For my part, I can’t accept his sentiment and so dismiss a thousand years of autonomous Scottish history!

We are democracy

Why elect a party, give it a healthy mandate to make the decisions we expect them to make, and then withdraw when it meets resistance? In what way is that responsible? Our responsibilities do not end with a cross on a ballot paper. Losing our nerve when the going gets tough doesn’t say much for our resolve. Of course, there was more to my friend’s resignation than sighing at petty squabbles in the media between politicians.

Being perceptive, my friend took note of the Tory Party in Scotland shamelessly signing up known neo-Nazis and fascist sympathisers to their colonial cause, and was appalled at the situation. Some phony candidates have taken to camouflage, canvassing under the banner of ‘independent’. If embraced by a political party their twitter account is cleaned up overnight, and the Facebook pages locked from public scrutiny. All is well, time for a photo opportunity with Ruthie, or Kezia, history sponsored by Cillit Bang.

Scotland wants to stay in Europe. We wish fervently to remain Europeans with all the benefits that that bestows. We voted No to full autonomy on the promise we remain Europeans part of the European Union. What we got is English nationalism.

Sell your pith helmet

We are witness to a disgusting right-wing resurgence of England as a colonial power, a last dying fart. Not all English are so disposed, not all see themselves riding the back of a camel like Lawrence of Arabia and telling Arabian tribes how to massacre Turks, or shooting elephant and tiger, just those who have power and those who want power.

Tory MP Liam Fox, international trade secretary, a man who’d have sold his incubator had he the physical ability as a baby to advertise it in the Times, describes England as, “A small island perched on the edge of the European continent that became a leader of world trade.” His predication fell apart soon as he mouthed it. Major foreign companies are talking of packing up shop and moving to Ireland or Europe, or going home.

Cue Edward Elgar’s ‘Land of Hope and Tory’.

Fox is one of those mini-monsters of politics, a Scot … on the make. In one sentence he reminds us of English foreign policy made simple: that all other nations are inferior.


Churchill’s  savage legacy

On top of doubt we’ve seen a reassessment of Winston Churchill’s legacy. Of Englishmen who dominated the British Empire, preeminent was Winston Churchill. Not often cited is Churchill’s infamous boast of killing “savages” in Sudan. He took part in raids as part of his duties, raids laying waste to whole valleys, destroying houses and burning crops. He bragged that he personally shot at least three “savages”.

As an MP Churchill demanded more conquests based on his belief that “the Aryan stock is bound to triumph”. As for the unfortunate children of savages killed, Churchill felt they would be  “glad to include themselves within the gold circle of an ancient Crown”.

His doctor, Lord Moran, opined that Churchill had a way of “judging everybody by the colour of their skin.” A British nationalist from his Cuban cigar to his ugly bulldog, Churchill advocated the troublesome little Kapher Gandhi be “bound and gagged and trampled on by elephants.”

He had his detractors. Churchill’s colleagues thought him antediluvian, not fit for promotion to high office, but he still became Prime Minster, and used his considerable dislike of Johnny Foreigner to beat ‘the Huns’ at their own game. It’s our luck Churchill and Nazism arose at the same time. Churchill knew a creed worse than his own.

Peas in a colonial pod

Today’s zealots opposed to Scotland’s constitutional progress embody the same Churchillian disdain of  ‘inferior’ nations asserting themselves. Given up offering alternative policies and false choice, they’ve taken to poisoning the waters. Scots, we’re told, are so obviously useless at anything, especially governing themselves, benign Westminster is compelled to rule us. In reality, the attack on our education system and NHS is just a variation of the racist argument. Our children are poorly educated, they aver, and we cannot heal the sick, because we are illiterate savages.

The blitz on liberal sentiment is cloaked in the moronically repeated phrase, ‘divisive politics’. If people spouting that idiocy were a building they’d be condemned.

But there’s amusement in seeing unionists getting hot under the collar while arguing that only Westminster rule keeps people cool, calm and collected. Westminster rule is often callous, inflammatory, and always reactionary.


Tory and Labour attacks abuse free speech with extreme racist opinions

To ignore racism is to invite it in

If readers still don’t see the struggle as democrat versus colonial they should have been present at UKip’s predicable chaotic launch of their racist manifesto. BBC’s Scots-born Laura Kuenssberg tried to ask a simple, straight-forward question and got silenced by jeers. “Learn to speak English!” she was told in no uncertain terms, and from people who pronounce ‘month’ as mumf.

A prime example of the English racist is the repulsive Katie Hopkins. Bile pours out her like molten lava, synthetic, fired up to shock. She wrote of Scotland’s First Minister, “the Ginger Dwarf from the North,” and the young SNP MP, Mhairi Black needed to learn “some useful life skills, like how to talk, write, or use shampoo.”

Hopkins wrote this in the wake of Manchester’s horrendous atrocity:

“22 dead – number rising. Schofield. Don’t you even dare. Do not be a part of the problem. We need a final solution Machester [sic].” [My emphasis].

She lost her job as a broadcaster for uttering that calamitous phrase, one Goebbels would have been proud to have coined, and probably did. The fans she inflames and incites are not happy that her soap box is getting shakier.

Rather than give in and accept her provincial abuse, wouldn’t it be pleasant to live in an nation where her ferocious stupidity was not a paid job? Hopkins has no attachment to anybody but herself. The thick end of a spatula of this world won’t go away if we cave in to their xenophobia for a quiet life. Do that and they will be bashing anybody with a dark skin they meet in the street.

A whole nation treated as backward

As I try to demonstrate when opportunity or necessity arise, attacks on Scotland’s integrity are nothing new. They’ve been part and parcel of colonial propaganda for centuries, well before the Union of 1707. The antipathy to open debate by unionists is telling. The divisiveness they claim is not pleasant for nice law abiding people does not exist. The more they say it is the result of tribalism, as they like to call it, but we know is  democracy at work, the more it has an affect on their attempts to tighten their grip on Scotland’s progress. The more the state suppresses, the greater the resistance to it.

Churchill lived to see stalwarts of the democratic spirit regain their lands – charismatic nationalist leaders such as Kwame Nkrumah, first leader of free Ghana, liberated from the British Empire in March 1957, Aung San in Burma, and Jawarlal Nehru in India.

They used Churchill’s own words and his braggadocio against him, as we will use the insults of today’s divisive racists to bury them and their hostility, once and for all.

Let’s build a society where those people cannot flourish.



This entry was posted in Scottish Independence Referendum, Scottish Politics. Bookmark the permalink.

14 Responses to A Churchillian Hatred

  1. Good morning.
    Another fine piece.
    Can I re-post on my website please?

  2. Grouse Beater says:

    You’re welcome! I’m typing letters, then a full day at meetings, not sitting in the sunshine!

  3. wullsg@sky.com says:

    Well written and incisive.
    Pity our MSM fear openness and tolerance.

  4. Grouse Beater says:

    Aye, a corrupt and ignorant right-wing press and their placemen in broadcasting, do all they can to keep their jobs and salaries safe.

  5. Fran says:

    Another good piece.
    Seems like the power of propaganda that the all conquering British State is having an effect on your friend, that is why blogs like yours and the work you do is important. Keep it up Grouse.

  6. Gordon McShean says:

    Having had to leave Scotland in 1958 (under a cloud because of my radical nationalist associations) I was subsequently honoured to be chosen to represent political science students at El Camino College, California during Earl Attlees’ visit there in 1961. I cited Churchill’s reported between-the-wars comment to Attlee,.”the best thing that could happen for Scotland would be the reestablishment of its parliament.” He responded at some length (quoted pp. 308 – 311 in my memoir RETIRED TERRORIST, Trafford, 2011), and closed with “He was known to say many silly things during his long and eventful life.”

  7. Statgeek says:

    Divisive – The word used by politicians to give a positive idea a negative reputation.

  8. Grouse Beater says:

    Gordon: I could never ascertain whether Churchill was playing to the gallery when he said that on visit to Scotland, or he really meant it, but like Douglas-Home and his promises, was told to zip it.

    Well done on your El Camino sojourn. I hope we hear more from you.

  9. Macart says:

    Neatly done Grouse and well expressed. No. I don’t feel like quitting either and I’m fond of the odd quote or two myself as you know.

    ‘A man who doesn’t stand for something, will fall for anything.’ Alexander Hamilton

    Then of course there’s another old favourite; ‘The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing’, attributed to Burke and a number of others, but the sentiment is pretty much pertinent at any time and from whatever source.

    Both are relevant today.

    You either stand against the bully, or you lie down and take the beating. You stand against what you know to be fundamentally wrong, or you share the blame for its growth. We’re only human. Most of us are just common five eight, and we can’t fight and right all the evils of the world, but I’d say we can stand against what’s right in front of us and make sure it goes no further. We do have it within ourselves to do that and do it at the ballot to boot.

    Worth remembering that the common five eight are what its really all about and they all have it within their own power to change the world created by a privileged few.

  10. Grouse Beater says:

    Macart: Everything Phantom does is praiseworthy. Portraits of people given long and careful thought to their vote is fine lesson in how to arrive at a destination by rational debate and comparisons. They’re people who realise the common good is better than individual needs.

  11. Macart says:

    Amen to that Grouse.

  12. Lanark says:

    A very thoughtful article. If anyone is interested in a measured response to a bellicose Churchill, they might find it worth listening to De Valera’s radio address in 1945 responding to Winston’s threat of invading Ireland. It’s easily found on the net.

  13. Grouse Beater says:

    Lanark: An excellent pointer to an instant history lesson! 🙂

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s